Most employers know OSHA exists. Fewer understand the details of what it takes to comply. And very few realize just how costly simple reporting mistakes can be—not only in terms of fines, but also in inspections, public exposure, and lost business opportunities.
For agents, that gap in knowledge is a goldmine. It’s a chance to start conversations in a place where most incumbents aren’t showing up, add immediate value, and begin building trust that leads to bigger opportunities down the road.
Why OSHA Mistakes Are a Big Deal
The fines alone are eye-opening. As of 2025, inaccurate or incomplete OSHA logs can result in penalties of $16,550 per violation, and willful or repeat violations can hit $165,514. Failing to submit electronically by the March 2 deadline can also land employers in OSHA’s Non-Responder Enforcement Program, meaning they're more likely to be prioritized for inspections.
But the costs don’t stop there. Underreporting injuries is usually the main concern, but over-reporting can be just as costly in other ways. Because OSHA publishes injury and illness data online, over-reporting can hurt a company’s reputation, damage its ability to win bids, and even tip off competitors.
In short: one “paperwork” mistake can have very real financial and reputational consequences.
Why This Matters for Agents
Here’s the best part: very few agents are talking to employers about this. Which means if you show up with insights about OSHA reporting mistakes, you’ll stand out instantly.
Employers expect agents to talk about premiums. They don’t expect an agent to know the ins and outs of OSHA logs, compliance deadlines, or the public cost of over-reporting. That’s your wedge.
By starting with OSHA compliance, you’re positioning yourself as an advisor who helps employers avoid risks they didn’t even know they had—not just a salesperson chasing quotes.
How to Use This Topic as a Door-Opener
The trick is not to overwhelm employers with regulations, but to give them something small, useful, and specific. That’s where a resource like The Real Cost of OSHA Mistakes handout comes in handy.
Here are a few ways to put it into action:
-
- Cold outreach: Send a short email or LinkedIn message offering the handout. “Most employers don’t realize that one OSHA log mistake can trigger thousands in fines or even an inspection. I put together a quick one-pager that explains the real cost of OSHA mistakes — would you like me to send you a copy?”
-
- In-person drop-off: Print the handout and deliver it with a brief note: “Thought this might be helpful as you’re preparing for February and March OSHA deadlines.”
-
- Warm touchpoint: Use it to re-engage a prospect who’s gone quiet. “I know we talked earlier in the year—here’s a quick resource I share with clients this time of year as OSHA deadlines approach.”
-
- Networking events: Keep copies on hand for chamber meetings or safety roundtables. It’s an easy leave-behind that positions you as the compliance-minded agent.
Using a handout like this for prospecting outreach is the perfect way to get in the door: low commitment, valuable, and sets the stage for a follow-up conversation.
How to Transition Into Comp Conversations
Remember, the goal isn’t to stop at compliance. OSHA logs are a bridge to bigger discussions about claims, the experience mod, and ultimately workers’ comp costs.
After you’ve shared the handout, the next step is to ask questions like:
-
- “How confident are you that your logs are accurate?”
-
- “Do you know how these OSHA records tie into your comp claims and your experience mod?”
-
- “Would you like me to take a quick look at your logs to see if there are any red flags that could impact both compliance and your premiums?”
From there, it’s a natural progression into claims management, injury trends, and cost containment—the areas where you can truly differentiate yourself and win business.
Next Step: Download the Handout
We’ve created a one-page infographic, The Real Cost of OSHA Mistakes, that you can use as a drop-off, email attachment, or LinkedIn content piece.
Download the handout here → The Real Cost of OSHA Mistakes.
Use it to open doors, add value, and position yourself as the agent who brings more to the table than just a quote.
Want to make OSHA recordkeeping even easier for your prospects and clients? You need OSHAlogs, the digital recordkeeping app that makes OSHA compliance a breeze for employers.
